I finally figured it out. Here is what I did.

1. Reinstalled SQL Server 6.5 on new machine and applied all service packs. Made sure that I gave the machine the same name as the old machine. Also made sure that I installed on the same drive as the old macine. During install I made sure that the MASTER device was the same size as the MASTER device on the old server.

2. Created all devices and databases that were on the old machine. I made sure that they were all the same size as the devices on the old server and all had the same name.

3. Shut down the SQL Server service.

4. Copied ALL recovered dat files over new dat files (including MASTER and including databases that I did not care about)

5. Re-started SQL Server.

Everything came up fine and I was able to access my old database from the server that had crashed! Thanks for all help on this problem.

Corey